Plush Vs Firm Mattress: Which Is Best for You?

Whether you’re team plush or team firm, you deserve a comfortable mattress that’s going to bring you sweet dreams and restful sleep. 

When deciding on a new mattress, how it feels under your body is a huge factor, after all, nobody wants to feel like their sleeping on a surfboard or couch cushion.   

Let’s talk about firm versus plush mattress and which one is best for you.  

The luscious feel of a plush mattress may suit side sleepers because of the extra cushion effect

What Is a Firm Mattress? 

A firm mattress ought to provide strong support under your body, without feeling like you’re sleeping on the floor. If you’re feeling a lot of pushback from your firm mattress (it’s pressing your pressure points into your body) the mattress could cause unwelcome aches and pains.   

What Is a Plush Mattress?

A plush mattress has a softer feel than a firm mattress that you’ll easier sink into. Plush firmness ought to cradle your body while offering pressure relief to every muscle without sinkage. A pressure relieving plush mattress will give you that soft feel you without aches and pains from lack of support.  

What’s the Difference Between Plush and Firm Mattresses?

Plush Mattress

Firm Mattress 

Suit any sleep style 

Might be best for back sleepers 

Body may feel as if it’s sinking into the mattress depending on materials used  

Could cause uncomfortable pushback depending on materials used 

Must be pressure relieving for optimal sleep comfort 

Must be pressure relieving for optimal sleep comfort 

Is it Better to Sleep on a Hard or Soft Mattress? 

What Are the Benefits of a Plush Mattress?

The luscious feel of a plush mattress may suit side sleepers because of the extra cushion effect. A plush mattress ought to provide an almost sinking feel without causing aches and pains. If you’re on the lighter side, a plush mattress may be a viable option for you to bring sleep comfort. 

What Are the Disadvantages of a Plush Mattress? 

If you suffer back, neck, or shoulder pain or you’re a stomach sleeper, a plush mattress may not be best for you. A firmer feel might provide more sleep comfort. A plush mattress might be unsuitable for couples as motion transfer might be an issue with the softest mattress design. 

What Are the Benefits of a Firm Mattress?

Firm mattress benefits could be felt more so in those who are not managing back, neck, or shoulder pain. What is a firm mattress anyway, a firm mattress ought to be pressure relieving and put minimal to zero strain on the muscles while improving blood circulation. A firm mattress could be suitable for stomach sleepers to minimize lower back pain.        

What aAe the Disadvantages of a Firm Mattress? 

Firm mattress meaning is simply a mattress that you may experience more pushback on than on a plush mattress. If making a sudden switch from a soft to firm mattress, you may feel slightly uncomfortable, to begin with, as your body adjusts to the new feel, it may take a week or two to feel the benefits.   

How Firm Should My Mattress Be? 

Mattress firmness will be determined by your;

  • Bodyweight 
  • Sleeping position 
  • Suffer back, neck, or shoulder pain 
  • Personal preference 

Stomach sleepers have special requirements because they sleep without a pillow

Plush vs Firm Mattress for Back Pain

An inadequate mattress can cause much pain and discomfort. If you’re a back or stomach sleeper and your mattress is too soft, you may end up with lower back strain. As a side sleeper, a soft mattress may prove more beneficial for your sleep health. When choosing between a firm or soft mattress for back pain, a mattress that is slightly on the firm side may be more comfortable.  

Plush vs Firm Mattress for Back Sleepers 

Soft mattress vs firm mattress for back sleepers may seem like an obvious choice. A firm mattress might be the most suitable for back sleepers to avoid any lower back problems. A pressure relieving mattress is the best option when choosing between a soft or firm mattress

Plush vs Firm Mattress for Back and Stomach Sleepers  

Stomach sleepers have special requirements because they sleep without a pillow. On a soft mattress, stomach sleepers could suffer lower back pain if their stomach sinks down into the foam as they sleep. When it comes to a firm or plush mattress for stomach sleepers, opt for firmer support.   

Plush vs Firm Mattress: Which Is Right for You? 

When choosing between a firm or soft mattress remember there are many other variations of mattresses out there to choose from. There are many types of mattresses in between a plush or firm mattress that will provide sleep comfort with varying degrees of comfort. 


Whatever your favored level of sleep comfort, it’s always best to opt for a pressure relieving mattress that will cradle every muscle in a supportive hug. 

A pressure relieving mattress will feel neither too soft or too firm, it will feel comfortably supportive. A firm vs plush mattress is subjective and will come down to your personal preference of mattress comfort. 

Compare and Shop Nolah's Premium Mattresses

Difference Between Plush and Firm Mattress

Soft vs firm mattress difference will be in its level of comfort, however, sleep comfort is subjective and will be different for everyone. A plush mattress will feel softer and sink the body deeper than a firm mattress. If you’re a stomach sleeper, a plush mattress could cause lower back strain so opt for a firmer feel. 

How Firm Should My Mattress Be?

If you’re dealing with back pain a firm mattress could prove more comfortable than a soft mattress. Firm mattresses might be best for back sleepers as they could help to align the spine better. Stomach sleepers could also find a firmer mattress more beneficial to their sleep health as their sensitive lower back region is supported. 

What Is a Firm mattress?

A firm mattress may feel a little rigid at first but after some time your body should become accustomed to the feel. As long as the mattress doesn’t give hard pushback, meaning your sensitive pressure points are not put under strain, a firm mattress could prove beneficial for stomach and back sleepers.