The Nolah Signature 12 vs Puffy vs Puffy Lux Mattress

Shopping for a new mattress can be a confusing and tiresome experience. With so many retailers and many choices available. We compare Nolah Signature 12 vs Puffy vs Puffy Lux to help you make an informed decision on your new mattress. 

Disclaimer: This comparison is based on publicly available information sourced from www.nolahmattress.com and www.puffy.com on the 24th day of June 2020. 

Comparison Table

Nolah Signature 12

Puffy Mattress

Puffy Lux Mattress 

Type of Mattress

High-Resilience Pressure Relief Foam

(Double-Sided)

Memory Foam / Foam

Memory Foam / Foam

100% Made in the U.S.A.

Yes – 100% made in the U.S.A.

Yes – 100% made in the U.S.A.

Yes – 100% made in the U.S.A.

Materials and Construction

4-Layer / 100% High-Resilience Foam

3-Layer / Memory Foam

4-Layer / Memory Foam

Price for Queen Size

$1,1,77

$1,150

$1,795

Trial Period 

120 Nights

101 Nights

101 Nights

Free Shipping & Return

Yes

Yes

Yes

Length of Warranty

Lifetime 

Lifetime

Lifetime

Firmness

Flippable Soft Side and Firm Side in 1 Mattress

Medium-Firm

Medium

 

Nolah vs Puffy vs Puffy Lux Mattress: What to Compare? 

  • Mattress Type
  • Country of Origin
  • What materials are they made of?
  • Price and Size Comparison
  • Delivery and Packaging
  • Trial Period and Return Policy
  • Length of Warranty
  • Firmness Rating
  • Pressure Point Relief
  • Cooling/Breathability
  • Durability
  • Off-Gassing
  • Typical Complaints
  • Which is best for your sleeping position? 
  • Which is best for hot sleepers?
  • Is Puffy Lux worth it?
  • Comparison Summary

Mattress Type

Are you a side sleeper, back sleeper, tummy, or combi-sleeper? Your search for a new mattress will be a lot easier when you know your sleep style. Your new mattress will be more comfortable if it’s designed with a particular set of sleep needs in mind. For instance, the Nolah Signature 12 is made with AirFoam™, a propitiatory and revolutionary mattress material not found anywhere else. AirFoam™ is suitable for all sleep styles but is particularly suited to side sleepers. As a side sleeper, the sensitive areas of hips and shoulders are most vulnerable, therefore, they require more targeted support. Choosing a mattress that is customized to your personal sleep needs guarantees far greater comfort and enhances sleep health better than a ‘ready-made’ mattress. 

The Puffy Lux and Puffy mattresses are designed to suit all sleep styles. However, side sleepers may appreciate the Puffy Lux, while the Puffy mattress could be suitable for all sleep styles. Mattresses that are designed to cater to all sleep styles may not provide the most optimal comfort. There is no one size fits all when it comes to mattresses. Sleeping on a mattress that does not support your primary areas of concern, could result in morning aches and pains or exacerbate current symptoms. Therefore, consider your sleep style before choosing a mattress type.     

Where are Nolah, Puffy, and Puffy Lux Mattresses Made?

Nolah Signature 12

Puffy Mattress

Puffy Lux Mattress 

100% Made in the U.S.A.

100% Made in the U.S.A.

100% Made in the U.S.A.

 

Shopping ethically is thankfully easier than ever. When you buy locally made products, you’re saluting your community and helping to keep a healthy local economy. Shopping ethically is acting patriotically while sustaining local businesses. The Nolah Signature 12 is 100% American made. All the materials used in their mattresses, foam, and cover are 100% made and assembled in the U.S.A. A lot of people ask, where is puffy mattress made? You’ll be glad to know the Puffy Lux and Puffy Mattresses are also made in the U.S.A. 

What Materials are They Made of?

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress 

The Puffy Lux Mattress 

High-resilience pressure relief foam (AirFoam™)

Conventional Memory Foam / Foam

Conventional Memory Foam / Foam

 

What is the Nolah Signature 12 Mattress Made of?

The Nolah Signature 12 is made of an innovative new AirFoam™ this pneumatic (air-filled) foam is made under high pressure and then crushed to blast billions of microscopic air pockets inside the foam. The Signature 12  is temperature neutral – meaning that it does not absorb and store heat. It stands 12 inches tall and is built in 4 layers with a breathable organic cotton cover.  It also gives you greater control of your sleep comfort because of its 2-sided design, giving you 2 sleep surfaces, soft and firm. 

What is the Puffy Original Mattress Made of?

The Puffy Mattress is made from conventional memory foam and is 10 inches tall. The foundation layer is 6 inches of support foam, the middle layer is 2 inches of climate comfort memory foam, with 2 inches of cooling cloud memory foam on top. The top layer is a gel-infused visco-polyurethane memory foam and includes a zip-off cotton cover. 

What is the Puffy Lux Mattress Made of? 

The Puffy Lux mattress has a 6-inch polyfoam base topped with 2 inches of firmer polyfoam, topped with 2 inches of soft memory foam, and 2 inches of gel memory foam. The Puffy Lux mattress is a 4-layer construction, stands 12 inches tall, and wrapped in a zip-off cotton cover.  

Why Does This Matter?

You will spend approximately ⅓ of your life in bed, your sleep comfort is also vital to maintaining good overall health and wellbeing. When you buy ingredients from the farmers’ market and cook a healthy meal, you feel nourished and happy. The same feeling of sleep nourishment and comfort is what to seek in a new mattress. A mattress that is made with memory foam contains heat-trapping viscoelastic chemicals and may not be the most healthy option. Choosing a mattress that is built using modern materials and sleep science research and techniques, could prove more beneficial to your sleep health and overall health and wellbeing. 

Nolah vs Puffy vs Puffy Lux Mattress Price and Size Comparison 

Mattress Sizes

Nolah Signature 12 Mattress Price

Puffy Mattress Price 

Puffy Lux Mattress Price

Twin

$802

$795

$1,445

Twin XL

$877

$825

$1,495

Full

$1,027

$995

$1,595

Queen

$1,177

$1,150

$1,795

King 

$1,327

$1,350

$1,995

Cal King

$1,327

$1,350

$1,995

 

Learn more about Mattress Sizes here: Mattress Size Guide

You don’t need to overspend on a mattress to find sleep comfort, no matter what your budget, there is a comfortable mattress for you. Consider your budget carefully when shopping for a new mattress. If the mattress you’re after is slightly out of your budget, the retailer ought to have an easy payment system in place, such as Klarna so you can pay for your new mattress over time. 

  • The Nolah Signature 12 mattress is available from Twin to Cal King size with a Queen size Signature 12 mattress priced at $1,177 and comes with 2 free pillows 
  • The Puffy mattress is available from Twin to Cal King with a Queen size priced at $1,150 
  • The Puffy Lux mattress is available from Twin to Cal King with a Queen size priced at $1,795 

Financing the cost of your new mattress is possible with Nolah and Puffy. Nolah offers 0% APR financing with Klarna over a 6, 12, or 24 month period. Puffy offers 20% APR financing with Klarna over 75 months. 

Delivery & Packaging 

Nolah offers free delivery and return in 48 states but does not deliver to Alaska and Hawaii. Puffy offers free delivery and return, but additional fees are applicable if shipped to Alaska and Hawaii. The packaging dimensions of Nolah and Puffy are:

Nolah Signature 12 

Puffy Mattress

Puffy Lux Mattress

Twin 38" W x 75" L x 12" H

Nolah 12” Original: 63 lbs

Twin 39" W x 75" L x 10" H

Puffy Mattress: 41 lbs 

Twin 39" W x 75" L x 12" H

Puffy Lux Mattress: 45 lbs 

Twin XL 38” W x 80”x L x 12” H

Nolah 12” Original: 67 lbs

Twin XL 39" W x 80" L x 10" H

Puffy Mattress: 45 lbs

Twin XL 39" W x 80" L x 12" H

Puffy Lux Mattress: 50 lbs

Full 54” W x 75”x L x 12” H

Nolah 12” Original: 78 lbs

Full 54" W x 75" L x 10"  

Puffy Mattress: 58 lbs 

Full 54" W x 75" L x 12"  

Puffy Lux Mattress: 63 lbs 

Queen 60” W x 80”x L x 12” H

Nolah 12” Original: 90 lbs

Queen 60" W x 80" L x 10" H

Puffy Mattress: 69 lbs 

Queen 60" W x 80" L x 12" H

Puffy Lux Mattress: 75 lbs 

King 76” W x 80”x L x 12” H

Nolah 12” Original: 107 lbs

King 76" W x 80" L x 10" H

Puffy Mattress: 87 lbs

King 76" W x 80" L x 12" H

Puffy Lux Mattress: 95 lbs 

Cal King 72” W x 84”x L x 12” H

Nolah 12” Original: 105 lbs

Cal King72" W x 84" L x 10" H

Puffy Mattress: 87 lbs

Cal King72" W x 84" L x 12" H

Puffy Lux Mattress: 95 lbs

 

The Signature 12 is a bespoke mattress. Your Nolah mattress only goes into production within 3 days of ordering so you get a mattress that is specially made for you. The Nolah Signature 12 leaves the US factory within 3-5 business days of ordering and will reach you within 5-10 days in total. The Puffy Mattress and Puffy Lux are 100% made in the U.S.A, therefore, shipped from their U.S. warehouse. 

Trial Period and Return Policy

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress

120-night trial

101-night trial

101-night trial


How to Return a Nolah Mattress?

Nolah offers free return within the 120-night free trial The returned mattress will be recycled where possible with a full refund given during this time. Simply contact customer care to begin the return process. 

How to Return Puffy Mattress?

Puffy mattress return is easy within their 101-night free trial. The returned mattress will be recycled where possible with a full refund given during this time. Simply contact customer care to begin the return process.  

Nolah vs Puffy Mattress Warranty

The Nolah Signature 12 is covered by a lifetime warranty as are the Puffy and Puffy Lux Mattresses.   

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress

Lifetime 

Lifetime

Lifetime

 

Nolah vs Puffy vs Puffy Lux: Mattress Properties

Firmness Rating   

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress

Soft Side 4-5 of 10

Firm Side 7 of 10

Medium-firm 6.5 of 10

Medium 5.5 of 10

 

Pressure Point Relief 

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress

Yes - especially for side sleepers

4x greater than memory foam 

Yes - may be a little too firm for side sleepers 

Yes - may be too soft for stomach sleepers 


Cooling / Breathability 

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress

Made of breathable AirFoam™ 

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals but the gel memory foam may offer some cooling

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals but the gel memory foam may offer some cooling

 

Durability 

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress

The mattress life expectancy of an AirFoam™ mattress is roughly 10 years

Memory foam mattresses typically have a 6-year lifespan 

Memory foam mattresses typically have a 6-year lifespan 



 

Off-Gassing 

Nolah Signature 12

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

 

It’s worth noting memory foam mattresses contain viscoelastic chemicals, these heat-trapping chemicals are known to typically make the mattress sleep hot. Nolah does not contain memory foam. 

Puffy Lux Mattress Complaints 

Typical complaints within Puffy lux mattress complaints say some stomach sleepers may need a more firm mattress to keep hips from sinking. Puffy lux mattress reviews also say that it could offer low motion transfer.  

Puffy Mattress Complaints 

The Puffy mattress could be ideal for those who enjoy that sinking feeling as opposed to feeling supported. It may also be too soft for stomach sleepers, who need firmer support to keep hips from sinking. 

Nolah Signature 12 Complaints 

The Signature 12 is low motion transfer so those who enjoy a bouncy mattress may find it unsuitable. Stomach sleepers should opt for the firm side of the mattress. 

Nolah vs Puffy vs Puffy Lux: Which is Best for Your Sleeping Position?

Brand 

Best for

Nolah Signature 12

Side Sleepers 

The Puffy Mattress

Back Sleepers 

The Puffy Lux Mattress

Side Sleepers 

 

Is Puffy Lux Worth it? 

For many, the Puffy Lux mattress is worth it as they are familiar with the feel of memory foam and enjoy the addition of the gel topper. The soft Puffy Lux mattress envelops the body to create a sinking feeling which may not be for those who enjoy a more supportive feel. If you’re set on sleeping only on memory foam and enjoy the soft feel, it could be for you.  

Comparison Summary 

Nolah and Puffy are respected mattress companies and you ought to expect a high level of customer care from each company. Mattress durability and price are two major concerns for anyone shopping for a new mattress. 

Memory foam mattresses contain heat-trapping chemicals so hot sleepers may not find the highest level of sleep comfort. Newer foam technologies could offer better quality and price than conventional memory foam. The Nolah Signature 12 mattress is 100% free from memory foam and designed to offer extraordinary support and comfort for side sleepers. Therefore, offering a more bespoke mattress. Nolah mattresses are made of 100% American materials in Nolah’s US factories and are made to order. Therefore, your mattress will only be produced after you place your order.    

Shopping online for your next mattress ensures you’re making the right decision because you have at least 100 nights to try in the comfort of your own home without obligation. 

Choose your next mattress