Tuft and Needle vs Casper vs Nolah Mattress

When shopping for a new mattress you want to know you’re getting the best deal and a long lasting mattress. Price, build quality, customer care, and comfort are factors you want to be sure of before making your purchase. With so many choices available. We compare Tuft and Needle vs Casper vs Nolah to help you make an informed decision on your new mattress. 

Disclaimer: This comparison is based on publicly available information sourced from www.nolahmattress.com and www.casper.com and www.tuftandneedle.com on the 21st day of July 2020.  

Comparison Table

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

Type of Mattress

Adaptive® foam / Poly Foam

Memory Foam / Poly Foam / Latex Foam

High-Resilience Pressure Relief Foam

100% Made in the U.S.A.

Yes – 100% made in the U.S.A.

No – US and Imported Materials

Yes – 100% made in the U.S.A.

Materials and Construction

2-Layer / Adaptive® foam / Poly Foam

3-Layer / Memory Foam / Poly Foam

3-Layer / 100% High-Resilience Foam

Price for Queen Size

$595

$1,095

$799

Trial Period 

100 Nights

100 Nights

120 Nights

Free Shipping & Return

Yes

Yes

Yes

Length of Warranty

10-Years

10-Years

15-years

Firmness

Medium-Firm

Medium

Medium Firmness


Tuft and Needle vs Casper vs Nolah Mattress: What to Compare? 

  • Mattress Type
  • Country of Origin
  • What materials are they made of?
  • Price and Size Comparison
  • Delivery and Packaging
  • Trial Period and Return Policy
  • Length of Warranty
  • Firmness Rating
  • Pressure Point Relief
  • Cooling/Breathability
  • Durability
  • Off-Gassing
  • Return Policy
  • Typical Complaints
  • Which is best for your sleeping position? 
  • Which is best for hot sleepers?
  • Comparison Summary

Mattress Type

When you know your sleep style, mattress shopping will become so much easier. Are you a combi-sleeper, back, stomach, or side sleeper? Many mattresses are designed to suit all sleep styles, but choosing a mattress that is built to cater to your specific needs could provide you with more sleep comfort. For instance, The Nolah Mattress is made with AirFoam™, a proprietary mattress material not found anywhere else. AirFoam™ is suitable for all sleep styles but side sleepers will appreciate the hip and shoulder pressure relief better than a ‘ready-made’ mattress. When we compare Tuft and Needle to Casper, both are designed to offer sleep comfort to all sleep styles. 

Mattresses that are made to suit all sleep styles may not provide the most pressure relieving comfort. There is no one size fits all with mattresses. Sleeping on a bed that does not support your major areas of concern, could bring morning aches and pains or exacerbate current health issues. Thus, find your sleep style before deciding on a mattress type.     

Where are Tuft and Needle, Casper, and Nolah Mattress made?

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

Yes – 100% made in the U.S.A.

No – US and Imported Materials

Yes – 100% made in the U.S.A.


When you buy locally made products, you’re contributing to your community and helping to keep a healthy local economy. Shopping ethically is acting patriotically and sustaining important local businesses. The Nolah Mattress is 100% American made. All the materials used in the mattresses, foam, and cover are 100% made and assembled in the U.S. When we
compare Tuft and Needle to Casper with regard to build location, Casper is made with U.S and imported materials while Tuft and Needle is made in the U.S.A. 

Construction and Materials Comparison 

 Tuft and Needle

Original Tuft and Needle

The Original Tuft and Needle mattress is made of 7 inches of high density polyfoam and 3 inches of Adaptive Foam. A simple design but could be attractive to those wanting to make a leap from an innerspring to foam mattress. 

Tuft and Needle Mint

The Tuft and Needle Mint is made of 7 inches of high density polyfoam, 2 inches of adaptive foam, and a further 3 inches of Adaptive Foam. The additional layer of foam allows sleepers over 230 pounds to enjoy a comfortable night’s sleep.

Tuft and Needle Hybrid

The Tuft and Needle Hybrid is a traditional hybrid design with A Tuft and Needle twist. A layer of pocketed innerspring coils are topped with transition foam, micro coils, and adaptive foam. A bouncy alternative to the Mint and Original variations. 

Casper

The Casper Original and Casper Hybrid

The Casper Original is made in 4 layers, 7.5 inches of polyfoam, 1.5 inches of zoned transition polyfoam, 1.5 inches of memory foam, and 1.5 inches of polyfoam. The Casper Hybrid is based on a 1 inch layer of polyfoam, topped with 6 inches of pocketed coils, 1.5 inches of zoned transition polyfoam, 1.5 inches of memory foam, and 1.5 inches of polyfoam. The Hybrid may offer more bounce and edge support.  

The Casper Essential 

The basic Casper Essential is a 7.5 inch base of polyfoam, topped with 1.5 inches of memory foam, and 2 inches of polyfoam. Could be a good entry level option for those who have never slept on memory foam. 

The Casper Wave and Wave Hybrid

Casper’s more luxurious option takes the form of the Wave and Wave Hybrid. The Casper Wave takes the form of 7 inch base polyfoam, 1.5 inches of polyfoam infused with targeted gel pods, 1.5 inches of memory foam, 1.5 inches of latex, topped with 1 inch of polyfoam. The Wave Hybrid consists of 1 inch polyfoam base, 6 inches of pocketed coils with foam encasing, 1.5 inches of poly foam with gel pods, 1.5 inch of memory foam, topped with 1.5 inches of latex and 1 inch of polyfoam. The wave may be more suitable to couples while the Wave hybrid could be a little bouncy for those sharing the bed.   

Nolah Mattress 

The Nolah Original 

The Nolah Original has a base of 7 inches of high density breathable foam, 1 inch of high resilience foam, topped with 2 inches of pressure relieving AirFoam™. This pneumatic (air-filled) foam offers a 100% temperature neutral sleep experience, thus, keeping you cool all night. 

The Nolah Signature 

The Nolah Signature is made of the same innovative new AirFoam™ as the original but with a twist. It is 1 inch of firm breathable AirFoam™ , 7 inches of high density foam, 1.5 inches of high resilience foam, topped with 2.5 inches of 100% temperature neutral AirFoam™. The flippable Nolah Signature is like 2 mattresses in 1. Giving you the choice of firm or soft sleep surfaces and more bang for your buck.  

Tuft and Needle vs Casper vs Nolah Mattress Price and Size Comparison 

Mattress Sizes

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

Twin

$350

$595

$499

Twin XL

$395

$695

$599

Full

$495

$995

$699

Queen

$595

$1,095

$799

King 

$750

$1,295

$899

Cal King

$750

$1,295

$899


Learn more about Mattress Sizes here: Mattress Size Guide

Never feel pressured into overspending on a mattress, which is why it’s best to shop online for your new bed, you don’t have any sales person looking over your shoulder, you're free to shop as you please without added pressure. Consider your mattress budget before making the purchase, if your chosen bed is slightly out of budget, online retailers should have a zero-low mattress financing option that allows you to spread the cost over time. 

Learn more about Nolah’s 0% APR mattress financing with Affirm. 

  • Tuft & Needle offer 0%-10.15% APR financing with Affirm over 3,6, or 12 months
  • Casper offer 0% APR financing with Affirm over 6,12, or 18 months
  • Nolah offer 0% APR financing with Affirm over 3,6, or 12 months 

Casper and Nolah offer more favorable financing options at 0% APR. If opting for 12 month financing with Tuft & Needle, expect to pay an additional 10.15% in APR.   

Delivery & Packaging 

  • Tuft & Needle offer free delivery and return in 48 states, additional charges apply for delivery to Alaska and Hawaii
  • Casper offers free delivery and return in US and Canada, in-home set (US only) and delivery to Alaska and Hawaii are at additional charges 
  • Nolah offers free delivery and return in 48 states but does not deliver to Alaska and Hawaii 

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

Twin 39" W x 75" L x 10" H

Tuft & Needle Mattress: 50 lbs 

Twin 38" W x 75" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 46 lbs 

Twin 38" W x 75" L x 10" H

Nolah 10” Original: 63 lbs

Twin XL 39" W x 80" L x 10" H

Tuft & Needle Mattress: 52 lbs

Twin XL 38" W x 80" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 50 lbs

Twin XL 38” W x 80” L x  10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 67 lbs

Full 54" W x 75" L x 10"  

Tuft & Needle Mattress: 63 lbs 

Full 53" W x 75" L x 11"  

Casper Mattress: 67 lbs 

Full 54” W x 75”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 78 lbs

Queen 60" W x 80" L x 10" H

Tuft & Needle Mattress: 72 lbs 

Queen 60" W x 80" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 79 lbs 

Queen 60” W x 80”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 90 lbs

King 76" W x 80" L x 10" H

Tuft & Needle Mattress: 94 lbs

King 76" W x 80" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 101 lbs

King 76” W x 80”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 107 lbs

Cal King 72" W x 84" L x 10" H

Tuft & Needle Mattress: 94 lbs

Cal King 72" W x 84" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 100 lbs

Cal King 72” W x 84”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 105 lbs


Tuft & Needle and Casper mattresses are factory made with some being shipped to their stores. If bought in store, there’s no way of knowing how long the mattress has been sitting in the storeroom. Nolah takes a different approach by offering only bespoke mattresses to their customers. Your mattress only goes into production within 3 days of ordering so you get a mattress that is specially made for you. Your Nolah AirFoam™ mattress leaves the US factory within 3-5 business days of ordering and will reach you within 5-10 days in total. 

Trial Period and Return Policy

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

100-Night Trial 

100-Night Trial

120-Night Trial


Length of  Warranty

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

10-Year Warranty 

10-Year Warranty

15-Year Warranty


Mattress Properties

Firmness Rating   

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

6.5/10 Medium-Firm 

6.0/10 Medium-Firm 

5-6/10 Medium Firmness


Pressure Point Relief 

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

may be a little too firm for side sleepers 

may be a little too firm for side sleepers 

4x greater pressure relief than memory foam, perfect for side sleepers 


Cooling / Breathability 

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals but the gel memory foam may offer some cooling

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals 

Made of breathable AirFoam™for a temperature neutral sleep  


Durability 

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

Memory foam mattresses typically have a 6-year lifespan

Memory foam mattresses typically have a 6-year lifespan 

The mattress life expectancy of an AirFoam™ mattress is roughly 10 years


Off-Gassing 

Tuft & Needle

Casper 

Nolah Mattress 

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified


Return Policy 

Tuft & Needle Return Policy

Casper Return Policy

Nolah Mattress Return Policy 

Free return within the 100-Night trial 

Free return within the 100-Night trial 

Free return within the 120-Night trial 


It’s worth noting memory foam mattresses contain viscoelastic chemicals, these heat-trapping chemicals are known to typically make the mattress sleep hot. Nolah does NOT contain memory foam. 

Tuft and Needle Complaints 

Some report the Tuft & Needle mattress is a little too firm for them, or the mattress is so light it slides off the base. Others say it sleeps too hot. *Tuft & Needle bed reviews are subjective, enjoy a free trial to gauge your own opinion 

Casper Complaints 

In some Casper mattress reviews, it’s reported that customer service is great but there has been some delays in delivery. Others report the mattress is too soft and sleeps too hot. *Casper bed reviews are subjective, enjoy a free trial to gauge your own opinion  

Nolah Complaints 

Strict stomach sleepers may find the Original 10 mattress a little too soft and should opt for the Signature 12 instead. The Signature 12 is flippable, offering a soft and firm side to choose from, with the firm side giving stomach sleepers even more pressure relief. Those with difficulty climbing into and out of bed should opt for the Original 10 as it’s two inches less in height than the Signature. *AirFoam™ bed reviews are subjective, enjoy a free trial to gauge your own opinion  

Which is Best for Your Sleeping Position?

Brand 

Best for

Tuft and Needle 

Back and Stomach Sleepers

Casper

Back Sleepers 

The Nolah Mattress

Side Sleepers 


Which is Best for hot Sleepers

The best mattress for hot sleepers is the 100% temperature neutral AirFoam™, with its billions of microscopic air bubbles that breath with you, pulling your body heat away from the sleep surface and out through the lower base levels. Hot sleepers finally have relief from heat trapping memory foam chemicals.  

Comparison Summary 

Tuft & Needle, Casper, and Nolah are respected mattress retailers. You should expect a high level of customer care from each of them. Mattress durability and price are two major concerns for anyone shopping for a new mattress. 

  • Tuft & Needle is reasonably priced at $595 for a queen size
  • The Casper mattress may be a little pricey for some at $1,095 for a queen size 
  • Nolah Original 10 is reasonably priced at $764 for a queen size (with 2 free pillows)

The durability of AirFoam™ makes it more value for money over a memory foam mattress. Many people report sagging issues within the first year of sleeping on a memory foam mattress. While some enjoy the heat of memory foam and how the body sinks into it, most people prefer the support of pressure relief over sinkage. 

It can be a difficult choice between Casper versus Tuft and Needle, Casper is more expensive but that doesn’t mean it’s better. They're both of similar quality. The Tuft and Needle price increase of up to 25% in 2017 was to cover the cost of their heavier foam, but, their current prices are still quite favorable for many. 

When it comes to Casper vs Tuft and Needle firmness, they’re relatively similar at around the 6/10 range of medium-firm. Tuft and Needle comparison in firmness to Nolah Original is also similar at around the 6/10 range. Mattresses like Tuft and Needle, Casper, and Nolah are best placed on a bed base. If you’re considering putting your mattress directly on the floor, learn more about sleeping without a bed base, here

A mattress free trial is the best way to decide if the mattress is for you, choose a company that offers free delivery and free return too. Then, all you need to do is sit and wait for the mattress to come to you. Save time and money by shopping online with a reputable mattress retailer. Try before you buy without obligation in the comfort of your own bedroom.   

Choose Your Next Mattress