Leesa Vs Casper Vs Nolah Mattress - Full Comparison

Shopping for a new mattress can be time consuming and confusing but it doesn’t need to be. Let’s put  Leesa vs Casper mattress vs Nolah to help you make an informed decision on your next mattress.  

 Disclaimer: This comparison is based on publicly available information sourced from www.leesa.com, www.casper.com, and www.nolahmattress.com on 13th November 2020. 

Leesa Vs Casper Vs Nolah mattress Comparison Chart 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Type of Mattress

Memory Foam / Polyfoam 

Memory Foam / Poly Foam 

High-Resilience Pressure Relief Foam

100% Made in the U.S.A.

Made in the U.S.A with US and Imported Materials 

Made in the U.S.A with US and Imported Materials 

100% made in the U.S.A.

Materials of Construction

3-Layer / Memory Foam / Polyfoam 

3-Layer / Memory Foam / Poly Foam

3-Layer / 100% High-Resilience Foam

Price for Queen Size 

$849

$1,095

$799

Trial Period 

100 Nights 

100 Nights 

120 Nights

Free Shipping & Return

Yes 

Yes

Yes

Length of Warranty 

15-Years

10-Years

15-years

Firmness 

Medium 

Medium

Medium Firmness

 

Leesa, Casper, and Nolah Mattress: What to Compare? 

  • Mattress Type
  • Country of Origin
  • What materials are they made of?
  • Price and Size Comparison
  • Delivery and Packaging
  • Trial Period and Return Policy
  • Length of Warranty
  • Firmness Rating
  • Pressure Point Relief
  • Cooling/Breathability
  • Durability
  • Off-Gassing
  • Return Policy
  • Typical Complaints
  • Which is best for your sleeping position? 
  • Which is best for hot sleepers?
  • Comparison Summary  

Mattress Type 

Do you know what your sleep style is and how it impacts your mattress shopping? You could be a side sleeper, back sleeper, stomach sleeper, or combi sleeper. If you’re wondering which is better leesa vs casper vs nolah for your particular sleep style, take note of how you’re positioned when you wake up in the morning as this is usually your default sleep position. Most mattresses are designed to suit all sleep styles, but choosing a mattress that is built to cater to your particular needs could provide more sleep comfort. The Nolah Mattress is made with AirFoam™, a proprietary mattress material not found anywhere else. AirFoam™ is suitable for all sleep styles but side sleepers will appreciate the hip and shoulder pressure relief better than a ‘ready-made’ mattress. The Leesa and Casper mattresses are made to suit all sleep styles. Therefore, may not offer special targeted support depending on your needs.

Where are Leesa, Casper and Nolah mattresses Made? 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Made in the U.S.A with US and Imported Materials 

Made in the U.S.A with US and Imported Materials 

100% made in the U.S.A.

 

Shopping ethically is acting patriotically by helping American businesses. The Nolah Mattress is 100% American made. When you speak to customer care, you can rest assured you’re speaking to someone based on U.S. soil. Leesa mattress is made in the U.S.A and Casper is made with U.S and imported materials. 

Construction and Materials Comparison 

Leesa

The Leesa Original is a 3 layer memory foam, polyfoam, LSA200 foam mattress and stands 10 inches tall. It is wrapped in a polyester cover that can be spot cleaned. 

Casper Mattress

The Casper Original mattress is a 3-layer foam mattress with additional zoned support around the shoulders and back areas. It has a zip-off cover and is 12 inches tall. 

Nolah Mattress

The Nolah Original has a base of 7 inches of high density breathable foam, 1 inch of high resilience foam, topped with 2 inches of pressure relieving AirFoam™. This pneumatic (air-filled) foam offers a 100% temperature neutral sleep experience, thus, keeping you cool all night. 

Leesa Vs Casper Vs Nolah: Price and Size Comparison 

Mattress Sizes

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Twin

$699

$595

$499

Twin XL

$749

$695

$599

Full

$899

$995

$699

Queen

$999

$1,095

$799

King 

$1,199

$1,295

$899

Cal King

$1,199

$1,295

$899

 

Learn more about Mattress Sizes here: Mattress Size Guide

Shopping online for your mattress will help you find the best deal and avoid the high pressure situation of sales staff in a brick and mortar store. Create a budget for your mattress and never feel pressured into overspending. If your chosen mattress is slightly out of budget, online retailers should have a zero-low mattress financing option that allows you to spread the cost over 3-18 months. 

Learn more about Nolah’s 0% APR mattress financing with Affirm.

  • Leesa Mattress offers 0%-30% APR financing with Affirm 
  • Casper Mattress offers 0% APR financing with Affirm over 3,6, or 12 months  
  • Nolah Mattress offers 0% APR financing with Affirm over 3,6, or 12 months 

Casper and Nolah offer more favorable financing options at 0% APR as you could end up paying 30% APR with Leesa.   

Delivery & Packaging 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Twin 39" W x 75" L x 10" H

Leesa Mattress: 45 lbs 

Twin 38" W x 75" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 46 lbs 

Twin 38" W x 75" L x 10" H

Nolah 10” Original: 63 lbs

Twin XL 39" W x 80" L x 10" H

Leesa Mattress: 48 lbs

Twin XL 38" W x 80" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 50 lbs

Twin XL 38” W x 80” L x  10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 67 lbs

Full 53" W x 75" L x 10"  

Leesa Mattress: 56 lbs 

Full 53" W x 75" L x 11"  

Casper Mattress: 67 lbs 

Full 54” W x 75”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 78 lbs

Queen 60" W x 80" L x 10" H

Leesa Mattress: 71 lbs 

Queen 60" W x 80" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 79 lbs 

Queen 60” W x 80”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 90 lbs

King 76" W x 80" L x 10" H

Leesa Mattress: 90 lbs

King 76" W x 80" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 101 lbs

King 76” W x 80”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 107 lbs

Cal King 72" W x 84" L x 10" H

Leesa Mattress: 92 lbs

Cal King 72" W x 84" L x 11" H

Casper Mattress: 100 lbs

Cal King 72” W x 84”x L x 10” H

Nolah 10” Original: 105 lbs


  • Leesa offers free delivery to all 50 states with a select few offering white glove delivery service for $150. You can also buy Leesa products from select brick and mortar stores, a store finder is on their website. There is a $100 return fee for those in Alaska and Hawaii 
  • Casper offers free delivery and return in US and Canada, in-home set (US only) and delivery to Alaska and Hawaii are at additional charges 
  • Nolah offers free delivery and return in 48 states but does not deliver to Alaska and Hawaii. The Nolah Original 10 (and Signature 12) is a bespoke mattress. Therefore, every customer receives a mattress that is made especially for them. The Nolah Original 10 goes into production within 3 days of ordering and leaves the US factory within 3-5 business days. Once it leaves the factory it will take a further 2-5 days before it reaches the customer. The Nolah Original 10 bespoke production and delivery take 5-10 days in total 

Trial Period and Return Policy 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

100-Night Trial 

100-Night Trial

120-Night Trial

 

Leesa Return Policy 

Return your Leesa mattress within the 100 night trial period to avail of free return. The returned mattress will be recycled where possible. There is a $100 return fee for those in Alaska and Hawaii  

Casper Return Policy 

Return your Casper mattress within the 100 night trial period to avail of free return. Those in Alaska and Hawaii who paid for delivery will get that refunded too. 

Nolah Mattress Return Policy

Nolah offers free return and will donate the returned mattress where possible. 

Length of Warranty 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

10-Year Warranty 

10-Year Warranty

15-Year Warranty

 

 

Leesa Vs Casper Vs Nolah: Mattress Properties   

Which is Firmer Leesa Vs Casper Vs Nolah 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

6/10 Medium-Firm 

6/10 Medium-Firm 

5-6/10 Medium Firmness

 

Pressure Point Relief 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Made of memory foam which is not the most pressure relieving material 

Some zoned support but made of memory foam which does not offer much pressure relief 

4x greater pressure relief than memory foam, perfect for side sleepers 

 

Cooling/Breathability 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals 

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals 

Made of breathable AirFoam™for a temperature neutral sleep  

 

Durability 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Memory foam mattresses typically have a 6-year lifespan

Memory foam mattresses typically have a 6-year lifespan 

The mattress life expectancy of an AirFoam™ mattress is roughly 10 years

 

Off-Gassing 

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

Odorless and CertiPUR-US® certified

 

Leesa Complaints

Some side sleepers say the Leesa Original is not suitable as it puts pressure on the hips and shoulders. Some find it to be too bouncy. 

*Leesa Mattress reviews are subjective, enjoy a free trial to gauge your own opinion  

Casper Complaints  

In some Casper Mattress reviews, some say the customer service is good but there has been some delivery delays. Others report the mattress is too hot. 

*Casper bed reviews are subjective, enjoy a free trial to gauge your own opinion  

Nolah Complaints 

Stomach sleepers may find the Original 10 mattress a little too soft and should instead opt for the Signature 12, which offers even more pressure relief. Those with difficulty climbing into and out of bed should opt for the Original 10 as it’s two inches less in height than the Signature. 

*AirFoam™ mattress reviews are subjective, enjoy a free trial to gauge your own opinion  

Which is Best for Your Sleeping Position 

Brand 

Best for

Leesa

Back and Stomach Sleepers

Casper

Back Sleepers 

Nolah 

Side Sleepers 

 

Which is Best for Hot Sleepers?

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals so could be uncomfortable for hot sleepers  

Contains heath trapping viscoelastic chemicals so could be uncomfortable for hot sleepers  

Made of breathable AirFoam™for a temperature neutral sleep  

 

Which Mattress is Better Leesa Vs Casper Vs Nolah

Leesa Original Mattress 

Casper Original Mattress 

Nolah 10” Original Mattress 

Combi sleepers may enjoy the Leesa Original, it is a reasonable price and widely available 

The Casper mattress is made to suit all sleep styles but is more expensive than Leesa mattress

Nolah Original 10 is unique in that it contains NO memory foam so sleeps cooler than memory foam mattresses, suits all sleep styles but side sleepers will particularly enjoy the targeted shoulder and hip support  

 

Comparison Summary  

In Casper vs Leesa vs Nolah, your choice will come down to your individual sleep needs. Some enjoy the extra heat of memory foam, others prefer the cooling sleep of AirFoam™. Leesa, Casper, and Nolah are respected mattress brands. You should receive a high level of customer care from each one. 

  • The Leesa Original Mattress is reasonably priced at $849 for a Queen
  • The Casper is a little pricey at $1,095 for a Queen 
  • The Nolah Original 10” is the cheapest and most durable at $799 for a Queen with 2 free pillows worth $198

The durability of AirFoam™ ensures you have a mattress that is built to last. Most memory foam mattress owners are unhappy with the quick sagging, typically within 1 year of ownership. 

While some enjoy the memory foam heat and how the body sinks into it, most people opt for the support of pressure relief over sinkage. 

Enjoy a free trial with Leesa and Casper for 100-nights. Enjoy a Nolah free trial for 120-nights. This is the best way to determine if the mattress is for you, in the comfort of your own home. Save time, money, and hassle by shopping online with a reputable retailer without obligation, safe in the knowledge of free delivery, free return, and lengthy warranties. 

Choose Your Next Mattress